Messed up my right click

[sesammy]

I installed Procaster, and right as I start it up it says

"Your computer is using the Aero scheme, which lowers the screen broadcasting rate. Do you want to switch to Basic scheme?"

I said yes to this and afterwards my right click is screwed up.
Attached is what my right click looks like now. I assume its associated with Procaster since it wasn't like that until this pop up happened after initializing Procaster; how am I to go about fixing this? Or is it not related to Procaster at all?

[sesammy]

I'm running MBAM right now in case I've a virus or something. So far no.

[ernielive]

sesammy,

Does this also occur if you manually change from Aero to Basic in Windows settings?