Maybe that was it. I was trying to increase the performance on my computer so I changed my scheme.
But doesn't procaster ask me to switch to a basic scheme? Or was it Aero? I don't remember.
Anyway, I tried it now and it does work with Aero on. Unfortunately, it skips incredibly, but I think that's just the fault on my computer. :/
Any suggestions on increasing performance? I know both Roxio and Procaster are using up ALL my CPU usage, so it makes it really hard to stream any of my PS3 stuff.